Idled Minn. Public Employees Holding On For Now

ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) — Kent Mechels spent the last three Christmases away from his family plowing snow off Minnesota roads so people could drive safely. It was a hardship he accepted as part of the job, he said.

But Mechels’ latest sacrifice — getting laid off during a state government shutdown now entering its second week — has him thinking about quitting.

“I’m looking at other state agencies in different states right now. I’ve lived in Minnesota my entire life. I may be leaving,” said Mechels, a single father from Rochester. “When the state government treats their employees like this, I don’t need to be part of it.”

Many of the 22,000 public employees out of work in Minnesota’s budget impasse say they will get through the extended layoff by tapping into personal savings, relying on a spouse’s income or unemployment checks, and making household spending cuts. But others are looking for new jobs, creating the potential for a brain drain that would be one more negative from the nation’s longest state government shutdown in a decade.

Erik Pakieser, an emergency planner for the state transportation department, took to Twitter soon after the shutdown to shop his services for what he hopes could be a better-paying job in the private sector. The state stands to lose an employee it spent a lot of money training, the St. Anthony Village man said.

“If I get a better job, great. If I don’t, I’m going to get my state job back eventually,” he said. “Who knows? Maybe there’s a silver lining in all this.”

Isaias Petros, of Minneapolis, works in land management with the Department of Transportation and said he doesn’t have much money saved to get through the shutdown. Though he is single with no children, Petros said he needs at least a temporary job to pay back some student loans.

“I was not ready for this,” he said, adding that he was actively looking for “anything” that could help him support himself.

Not everyone is job hunting.

Brent Anderson, who manages Whitewater State Park in southeastern Minnesota, has a wife who works and said he simply plans to cut back on expenses. Anderson is spending more time volunteering at the Goodview Fire Department, catching up on paperwork and thinking about painting his house trim.

One of the biggest shutdown casualties in Anderson’s family is his teenage daughter. She was scheduled to take her driver’s license test last Tuesday and was excited about getting behind the wheel. Now she’ll have to wait because the state is not offering driving tests during the shutdown.

“It’s a little disappointment for a 16-year-old,” Anderson said.

Jim Ullmer, of Crystal, a commercial vehicle inspector for the Department of Public Safety, has been babysitting his 18-month-old granddaughter, who he took to an anti-shutdown union rally at the Capitol last week.

“We’ve cut back and skipped a lot of things just in preparation,” Ullmer said. “Right now I’m just babysitting little Anna. … She’s a full-time job and I love doing it, but I’d much rather be out doing my job.”

Ullmer also has been spending time on the phone. He’s the chief steward statewide for members in his agency who belong to the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees. He tells members curious about how long the shutdown will last to call their legislators.

“Ask them. They’re the ones who are keeping us out here,” Ullmer said.

The workers’ money woes contrast sharply with the position of state lawmakers, who are still eligible for their salaries during the shutdown — although some have chosen not to take them. And while their unions are a traditional power base for Democrats and support for Dayton remains strong, it’s not universal.

Brian Lindholt, of Minneapolis, says Republicans could end the shutdown simply by meeting the Democratic governor halfway.

“This is real. This is not a joke,” said Lindholt, a father of three who works for the Department of Transportation. “This is real life and we’re without a job right now because … they are holding the majority as legislators so they think they can strong-arm the governor.”

But Pakieser, who belongs to the Minnesota Association of Professional Employees, criticized the unions for their close alliance with the governor.

“I feel like Dayton has gone out of the way to mislead people about his compromise attitude,” Pakieser said. He said a video is circulating on YouTube of Dayton imploring lawmakers in February to join him in pledging not to shut down the government, yet Dayton vetoed all major state agency funding bills Republicans passed at the end of the session.

“It just looks to me like he wanted to force a shutdown. … He chose to spread maximum pain throughout the state government,” Pakieser said.

Some, like Mechels, say both parties deserve blame.

“They’re hired to do a job,” Mechels said. “They’re not doing their job, and they’re using us for pawns.”

(© Copyright 2011 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

  • Frank

    Pakeeser is an idiot for saying what he did.. What does he gain from his statements. The others must be assured that there is no one in the enforcement division for when they check yes they looked for work on their unemployment

    • nica

      I wholeheartedly agree!

  • Gov. Mark

    his remarks are marinating in self pity.

  • Vote for Emmer

    Well, you get what you voted for!

  • Norge

    Good-Bye..if you need dierctions google them, tired of paying you union-goons twice what you deserve anyway, get outta here, you will NOT be missed. The lame-stream ‘Cco daily puff-piece for the left-wing union-goon-driven political action committees. TANSTAAFL!! Keep it shut-down till Daytons and the DFL/socialist/welfare-state public-trough-feeders brain-cells start working again! Spend a couple of Christmases in a foxhole with people shooting at you, for 10% of what you are making now, before you try to play the “pity-pot” card!! What a bunch of foolishness and waste of resources putting out this rubbish!

    • Randy

      Hey Norge! I served my country by giving over four years of my life to the United States Navy. I worked hard to get where I’m at, and I am proud to be able serve the citizens of the state of Minnesota. If you’re jealous for what we are getting paid, then shut your mouth and apply for a job. Ifffff you’re good enough, you might be able to get one of these good jobs. :)

    • Michele

      So, Norge, you volunteering to get up out of your bed and shovel snow come November?

      • Jake

        Actually, I had to use my snowblower just to get out of my neighborhood at least a couple of times last winter, because the SNOWPLOWS hadn’t plowed my local streets fast enough. Should I have sent a bill to my city??

        • Eat it Kitty

          Those are CITY plows, not the State nor Mn/DOT. I bet you advocate for less taxes and then I see you wine like crazy when it takes more time to plow the roads, the police to show up or the fire department to answer the fire calls. Perhaps the two are related…

          • Jake

            Ah, that’s true, but when I hit the STATE HIGHWAYS, they aren’t always plowed very well either, I’m only able to drive on them because the snow is packed down well enough for me to troge along at 30 mph. The fire dept has NEVER been to my house in the 20+ years I’ve lived here, so I expect them to show up PRONTO if I should EVER NEED THEM. The police will get here just fine if they have a good enough reason to show up. I know from experience.

            • paul

              yes send you bill to the city and see what happens I’ll bet money that your city won’t pay you !

          • Jake

            Funny, how you couldn’t even answer the QUESTION that I presented. Typical gov’t employee response. Blame somebody else.

            • Jake

              Incidentally, I pay CITY TAXES AS WELL, and they haven’t been going down, they have been going UP.

            • frozenrunner

              Putting people in a box as you did “typical government employee” is very small minded of you. I really think you should bring every armament you own, or anyone else you know, to the next city council meeting and demand the city pay you $100/hr for services rendered. Being that the police have been to your house I kind of figure that you might have to use other people’s wapons.
              Blaming other? Your name has been on this board enough to have read the right blames the left and the left blames the right.

    • Stien


      Can you point me to one of these State jobs that pay twice as much? I need to get me one of these! Bent over LMAO!

  • Bobby redbone

    What a bunch of slugs ! Keep it shut down , these slugs have had it to good for to long ! I work with mn dot . When we do the same task with private contractors we have a pre job meeting with about 3 people . When it’s mn dot about 15-17 all paid for by us the tax payers!

  • Nols

    Hey Norge why don’t you try teaching the kids or fixing the roads….Police corrections….lace up your boots. Military or not….are these people not worthy of a decent wage? They don’t make 100k a year like the dems and repubs do they? All make half of that or less buddy. Next time know what your talking about before you spew at the mouth. Its not about Unions right now. They are taking food off the table of Minnesotans period…

    • Jake

      Do you mean like the bus drivers in Madison, WI, who made over $150K in 2009?? Piling on the OT when they could have hired another driver at STARTING WAGE, instead of paying a senior union member DOUBLE TIME at the HIGHEST WAGE??
      Is that what you mean?? It’s all over the internet. LOOK IT UP.

      • frozenrunner

        Didn’t have to wait long to see you do the blame thing. You blame the union workers for going to work and working all they can. Perhaps when you actually read the story much of the time is due to a city hiring freeze. Again you blame the worker for taking advantage of the situation.

      • Nica

        Who is talking about WI? This is a Minnesota state shut down. Hopefully you know that!

      • Stien

        We ain’t in Wisconsin son!

  • Ali

    What a BIG joke. In a few years Public employees will go on strike to demand yet better wages and pensions then the private sector. Then a government shut down will be “Oh such a great thing…” we see through you phoney people and know that you are just a bunch of ” I , me. my. what more do I get
    clowns”. We need to stop all life time Public Union pensions NOW!!! You that have them keep them but NO NEW ONES!!! We need a real man like walker to get this done.

    • Stien


      No actually the will have their wages frozen for thre more years like it has been for the past 4.

  • Larry

    Yep they are already planning a strike with the slogan…”remember the last government shutdown, give us wat we want….”


    tipical republican responses they know how to can people names ! I don’t here any constructive ideas on how to end this travisty of justice . To the republicans if you can’t say anything nice then SHUTUP until you have a idea on how to end the shutdown caused by your republican legislators ! I’m a very proud Minnesota employee and norge I know you cannot do my job so I’m well worth what I make because I put my life on the line everyday in my job !

    • Rico Suave

      Well spoken, my brave, brave public employee. Let me guess, you’re also a product of our wonderful public schools as well. Actually if you put your life on the line as a public employee, that worries me a great deal. These days if the word public is in it, it’s a safe bet that you should not expect quality.

      • P SMITH

        Rico why don’t you just go back to where you came from it is apparent that you are NOT A MINNESOTAN !!!!!!!

    • Jake

      I have a solution. Tell the governor to sign the BUDGET. If it doesn’t work out like you would like, you can put in a dfl led majority in the Legislature in 2012, then jack up the taxes through the roof, then watch as company after company leaves the state, putting even more people on unemployment and bringing in less revenue to the state. Gee, we will look just like Mexico in NO TIME. Having this ‘quality of life’ means NOTHING if you don’t have a paycheck coming in.

      • CHESTER

        better yet why don’t you Jake,rico and all the rebublican lovers all go to Mexico

      • Michele

        Yes, company after company will leave and move someplace more profitable, like Arkansas. The CEO’s will move their families there, put their kids into school there, drive the unplowed roads there. And they will court people out of college to move there. Cause there’s … what?

        I’m getting sick of this lame blackmail.

        • Jake

          They may move to Arkansas, or Mississippi, or S. Dakota, but you can be sure that there kids will probably go to a private school and an out of state, prestigious college. Unplowed roads? They don’t get that much snow, not much need for snowplow drivers down there. Haven’t you heard about all the global warming going on?

        • Rico Suave

          Or maybe they’ll move to Maryland where they just decreed that kids have to be studied up on environmentalism to graduate. That’d be sooo cool. The only 2 words your kids could spell would be Global and Warming but wow, look at that great, liberal quality of life. I feel sorry for your kids and you if you’re in Minnesota for the public schools. Have you seen some of the posts of these MN educated public employees? I keep hearing liberals crow about the MN quality of life who apparently think that spending more equals higher quality. Dupes all!

          • P SMITH

            the public school system is good in Minnesota ……………………..were did you go to school Rico suave ?

        • Katie

          The best companies don’t go to locations because of taxes, they go to locations because of where they can get the best employees – unless their jobs can be done by any interchangable cog. San Francisco and NYC are not low tax places, yet many, many companies locate there. Same for all the big cities.

          Why do they go there? Because of the employee talent and because of the prestige of being in those locations. Same for Minneapolis – it’s one of the magnets for the best young professionals in the Midwest because it has good schools, good quality of life and a lot of cultural events. Young professionals today choose where to live based on the life they want instead of where they’re offered a job, and Minnesota wins over Arkansas hands down in that aspect.

          Saying high taxes = companies leaving oversimplifies the issue and assumes that low taxes are a higher priority to companies than access to the best employees.

          Michele is right for calling this lame blackmail. Let’s look at what really keeps companies around before we start pointing fingers at taxes. (With all the tax breaks big companies get, they barely pay taxes anyways.)

    • Richard Korte

      What is your judge sir? Public toilet scrubber Can’t imagine its anything to special. Because someone with a position of pristiage would have a little more class and not pressume that someone they have never met could infact do there job better. Quite simply put, dont worry your food stamps will be here on time

    • Proud of GOP

      Governor DAYTON caused the shutdown by vetoing the GOP passed balance budget that raised spending only modestly. Dayton violated his campaign pledge not to shut down state government for a tax increase.

  • ed

    “. . . But Mechels’ latest sacrifice — getting laid off during a state government shutdown . . . ”

    What an amazing sacrifice.

  • P smith idiot

    P smith , you are a loser , u don’t put your life on the line ! Please quit now andove to another state loser! U r a slug !

    • P SMITH

      P smith idiot you don’t know me at all you are a ja__a__ and a Slug unless you know what I do don’t make any stupid ass comments …………………why don’t you dry up and blow away

  • Al

    While I sympathize with the workers there are ten of thousands of Minnesotans in the private sector that have been out of work for far longer than a week to say the least. Many of these are in the building industry that was most deeply affected by political decisions allowing mortgages to be handed out as quickly as welfare checks. Now the public employees feel a little pain and everything is a crisis. I am disgusted with the fact they do not understand that you cannot sustain and economy that makes nothing. As soon as this country went over the 50% threshold of service jobs instead of manufacturing we were on the decline.

    • Waste

      Thank you for that post.
      The housing stimulus hid the fact that unemployment was on the rise in the Bush years.
      Now the dems want to spend even more, just because their predecessors did.
      When will we wake up, spend within our means and reward hard work again?
      If all of you state employees are hard workers, why aren’t you calling Dayton and telling him to sign the lights on bill?
      How a state worker can put a post on here without mentioning Dayton declining a lights on bill boggles my mind?

      • Richard Korte

        it is truelly amazing that no pro dayton supporter has not even made mention to that. He wants another 1.5 billion and some change for extra revenue, but not a lights on bill while they decide where to come up with that money. interestingly irony

      • Mike

        Why don’t you wake up. The greatest prosperity this country has ever seen was we taxed and spent which created jobs, highways, construction, research, etc. The wealthy were paying far far higher tax rates than they are now (anywhere from 50-90%) under both Democratic and Republican administrations. And guess what, this country flourished. Then the rich got greedy. Corporations didn’t want to pay taxes, the wealthy needed lower taxes, the population kept growing and the gap between rich and poor kept growing larger. Greed kills and will be the end of our economy. Wake up and smell the coffee…republicans only want one thing….your money at your expense!

      • mike

        Why don’t you wake up. The greatest prosperity this country has ever seen was we taxed and spent which created jobs, highways, construction, research, etc. The wealthy were paying far far higher tax rates than they are now (anywhere from 50-90%) under both Democratic and Republican administrations. And guess what, this country flourished. Then the rich got greedy. Corporations didn’t want to pay taxes, the wealthy needed lower taxes, the population kept growing and the gap between rich and poor kept growing larger. Greed kills and will be the end of our economy. Wake up and smell the coffee…republicans only want one thing….your money at your expense! They get richer, the rest of us get poorer, and the country and economy suffer.

        • Jake

          Then thank Bill Clinton, who signed NAFTA, GATT, Free Trade with China, the 1996 Telecom Act, gave away all kinds of government secrets to the Chinese, especially in defense and space, and now, he’s worth at least $200 Million. All of these changes didnt’ happen overnight, he know he would be out of office and could blame is successors for the unreversible DAMAGE that he did to America.

    • Sean

      @ Al The Bush job growth plan was that we send manufacturing jobs overseas and make money of managing them.

    • Citizen

      @Al. Actually, the banks are the ones who handed out mortgages like candy to people who came looking for a mortgage WHO SHOULD NEVER HAVE QUALIFIED. There were many instances of banks falsifying incomes so people could qualify when they otherwise could not. The feds simply wanted to stimulate home buying. No one asked the banks to commit fraud. I don’t know about most people, but I expect my banker to be honest and tell me if I can afford something or what the actual cost will be to me after checking my credit and finances. Banks DID NOT DO THE PROFESSIONAL JOB expected of them which caused the housing market meltdown. You need to read a little deeper than the propaganda. Of course, then the government bailed out the banks–should have nationalized them instead. Derivatives are still being used–twice as much lately. The banks are still going down a dangerous & slippery road…

  • DBB

    Why is it everyone thinks MN/DOT employees are overpaid? What is a fair wage for working on an interstate with trucks flying by at 70+ mph just feet from you. Would you do it for $21/hr? Average AFSCME salary is less than 40K.

    • BeenThereDoneThat

      I would love to make 40K ..and I have a degree. No pity here.

      • Les Johnson

        If you don’t, it’s probably your own fault.

        You make less than $20 bucks an hour and you have a college degree? Talk about “no pity here.”

  • Kevin

    Who cares? We have all gotten kicked by the economy! Its about time State workers get cut back!!!

    • Barney

      You realize that you beloved GOP Gov TPaw oversaw these employees for the last 8 years, right?

      How many did he “cut back”?

      Yeah, that’s right – some, but not as many as he wanted to. Why? Because as long as there are laws to be enforced, overseen, programs to regulatre, administer, then there needs to be employees.

      You can only cut so many without changing things drastically.

      Until we stop funding and overseeing every help organization for everyone who has a disability, needs money, needs food, needs education, needs 24-hr medical care, then there will be employees needed to do/oversee these laws and programs.

      So, which ones would you cut? Hospice care regulation? Autism centers? Job banks/ training prgrams? Bank regulations? Environmental regulations (feel free to dump toxic waste anywhere, 3M).

      You pick it – copntact your legislators and tell them to cut it.

      That is how you pare down employee rolls!

      • Recall

        Whoa there Barney. Whoa, whoa, whoa. What you listed is all well and good. But “cut”—is a bit drastic of a strategy. Why not scrutinize, reduce, or investigate out the fraud?

      • Jake

        Barney Fife,
        I recently read a report that said that 37% of our entire state’s budget went into some kind of WELFARE PROGRAM, the highest percentage of a state’s overall budget in the NATION. Don’t you think that there is some kind of PROBLEM with THAT? I certainly do. Yet, dayton is holding out for ANOTHER BILLION DOLLARS over what the legislature has proposed, and the legislature has granted at least a billion dollars more in THIS budget than the LAST budget allocated. Clearly, there is something wrong here, wouldn’t you like to know about it? I sure would. It’s time to take a CHAINSAW to the WELFARE BUDGET, and I’m not talking about throwing granny under the bus. I’m talking about telling the FREELOADERS to move to another state, and cutting state and county staff who administer these fraudulent programs, before they break our financial back.

        • Recall

          Now that’s what I’m talkin about.

          • Jake

            Effin A. It’s nothing but a Ponzi scheme, makes Bernie Madoff look like a Boy Scout.

            • Recall

              What’s worse, these people get their welfare–and have 5 years to get kicked off it and work! You or I wouldnt take 5 days to get a damn job. Welfare to work my a@!

              • Jocleyn

                Not everyone has the brains like you do. :-) Many people may be more unfortunate than you; jobwise, healthwise, that may prevent them from getting a job within 5 days. I just dislike the lazy ones who are on welfare and don’t want to put effort in finding work, but for those , who are in truly needs of financial help, I don’t mind paying taxes for that. Help one another in need is what every community needs to do, seems so, every comment I read in this article has to do with greed. Pretty sad.

                • Recall

                  100% agree. I would never throw the legitimate into my statements.

                • Jake

                  I’ve seen two of my siblings lose their jobs over the past year. They are good, law-abiding, DRUG FREE citizens. Guess what — they BOTH found jobs within 6 months, and at least one is getting paid MORE than he/she did in their previous job.
                  So, good, hard work pays off — eventually, somebody will recognize them for what they are capable of, and pay them accordingly. Who would have thought???

                • Jocleyn

                  Jake, that’s very great for your siblings. But, I am speaking about those who don’t speak English as a primary language. :-) Or, those who have no resources or don’t know about resource agents and etc. You can say tough luck for them, in other words, but, you can’t really be the one to say, if you have never been in their shoes. You’re complaining about welfare/public workers/etc, when you have never had to worry about what to do if it’s been months or years without a job, after interviews after interviews. Believe it or not, there are people who have gone through this kind of situation. And, are still trying to find jobs out there, and ARE DRUG-FREE, FYI!! Good people, who just happened to not be able to care for themselves in this ever-so changing economy. And, NOT everyone has the same values as you, so, it could explain why many people set off foot on a bad path to begin with. Don’t be too quick to judge; statistics are just numbers, start looking at the bigger picture, it ain’t just the liberals, or Dems who are causing havoc to this economy, it’s also the reps. Both sides are accounted for what has happened. One side wants to spend more, whereas, the other side, too greedy with what they have. The rich may feel that they worked hard to get to where they are, which, they did, but I’ve seen many whom lie and cheat to steal from many people, too. Gotta meet halfway to make things work.

            • Nica

              Jake, I have seen two friends and a relative lose jobs over the past two years. All three of them are hardworking, drug free, decent, law abiding citizens. One is still looking for work after 10 months, one was looking for a year and one has been out of work for 3 months. None of them have needed welfare because they qualified for unemployment but if they had needed it, it should be there for them.
              Please report all people you have evidence of who are cheating the welfare system. No one wants people receiving aid who don’t deserve it. And since you personally know so many people on welfare – I suggest you change the type of people you hang with. Or, are you just spouting your mouth off about something you have no direct knowledge of???

        • mj

          I agree Jake. I think the welfare budget for one year is 11 Billion.

          • Jake

            Yeah, that’s like $5,000 for EVERY man, woman, and child in Minnesota, and that doesn’t even count what you pay in property taxes, or other local taxes, which adds probably another 50% to that total. Think about it. Then try to make the arguement to me that taxPAYERS (whether rich or middle class) aren’t paying enough. So tell me, MN taxpayers, are you getting what you are paying for?

        • Jocleyn

          There’s something wrong with the increased rate in welfare, but I am pretty sure, the majority who are on welfare certainly relates to the increased rate on unemployment rates, too. Think about it.

          • Jake

            I was not born yesterday, and if you NEED me to quote all kinds of statistics to prove my point, then you are LLOST already. Welfare fraud is all over the place, and it is underreported. Those who do get caught don’t pay nearly the type of penalty that they should. The whole system is a joke, and you won’t find a single gov’t employee who will condemn it, because their job depends on it.

            • Really?

              Right on the money Jake. There’s a reason MN has the largest Somali community and has gang bangers from Chicago killed in north Mpls. every day. The welfare system here in MN is what entices them and I’ve heard that straight from the horse’s mouth. I would cut welfare totally. We SSI for disabled.

            • Jocleyn

              What do you do as a living, if you don’t mind me asking? I am pretty sure there are flaws in the system, but, who says any one program or system is perfect? That’s not new news, is it? Nothing is perfect. Either way, there are ALWAYS pros and cons to any kind of situation/program/etc. I made my point in the other comment about statistics. :-) Numbers that can also be incorrect, Jake, due to fraud and inaccuracy. You just contradicted your point.

            • mj

              You nailed it again Jake. Their job depends on growing the welfare rolls.

          • mj

            Welfare slug from other states are moving here for the benefits. I attended a neighborhood meeting when a new homeless shelter was being built. The shelter manager told us taxpayers that 40% are from out of state. You must be young cause I lived in apts full of welfare moms in the 70’s. They were given vouchers to pick out new furniture, etc.

            • Jocelyn

              MJ; I’m young? Younger than you, possibly. But, I am basing my views from experience. And, no, I am not on welfare if you wonder. WERE ON it before; know what it’s like. Had I come from a smart (and by smart, it could be any smart/intelligence; streetsmart, academically smart, etc) and wealthy family, I think I may see and maybe, understand a tad bit of your views. I wouldn’t need to start where I started from, rock bottom.

              For those who mentioned about the race/ethnicity that were surveyed as the highest consumers for welfare, If viewing on the Somalians as if they’re bad influence, then, imagine any one American moving outside of the U.S. to Africa and with of no help or few help, I’m pretty sure most of some Americans (wealthy ones stripped of money and no income, to start from nothing) may want to apply for some resource for help to survive if Africa had such a program like ours, welfare system. Reason to relocate would be, say, if U.S. were a 3rd world country and Africa had upgraded and have a better system. About the gangs and what not? Murders/Stealing/etc are terrible habits, that none should practice, yet, some choose to do it anyway. That’s their wrongdoings and lost on their end.

        • frozenrunner

          Is there some reason why you could not read for yourself on the budget. If you call all of the health and human services department welfare then yes it is 37%. Did you bother to look up what percent goes to the freeloaders and compare it to others? MFIP (welfare) goes to approximately 3600 families statewide and makes up 0.05% of the state budget.

    • Stien

      You are right Kevin! Get those tax paying citiizens on unemployment and keep the tax revenue down. And with less money for these folks, less money being spent in the almighty private sector. Someone how I miss your logic!

  • Jake

    Mr. Mechels, thank you for your service, plowing roads on Christmas Day, along with many others that you might have had better plans for. That being said, I wish to inform the rest of the citizenry, that at least SOME of us in the private sector, who are union as well, work on HOLIDAYS, WEEKENDS, NIGHTS, EVENINGS, virtually anytime, day or night, when called upon, and sometimes have to drive on UNPLOWED roads and highways during the winter, and we don’t drive 4WD vehicles either. We are as necessary as snowplow drivers, law enforcement, air traffic controllers, and others who help ensure the public’s safety and ability to function above a third world level. When we get laid off, when our pay gets frozen, or when our benefits get cut, we don’t get anywhere NEAR the amount of media attention that a monopolistic entities like union government workers get, who are put on such a pedestal. The lack of balance and perspective is astounding. Yes, I have heard that some gov’t workers have started to lose their jobs over the past year, but I can assure you that the private sector has been shedding good paying jobs, and a lot of union jobs, for over 5 years now. Too bad that ‘cco hasn’t discovered that phenomenon, with all of the ‘tweeters’ and facebook people out there.

  • Oops


  • DBB

    Hey Kevin I respect your comments but why hammer the state workers? I agree that one of our many problems is funding pensions. I am young enough that I don’t expect a pension because I don’t see any way states can continue funding them. Before we hammer state workers lets address the bigger problems like WELFARE and Government WASTE!

    • Kevin

      State Union workers and welfare and waste are one and the same DBB…..and I repsect your views also…thank you…

      • DBB

        Man you really don’t like those state workers! Unfortunately, your views are shared by many. It is a common stereotype that all state workers are pieces of s**t. I will be the first to admit that those types are out there and the union seems to protect them. I care very much for the quantity and quality of my work. I don’t know where you live,but where I live and work, workers like me far out number the ones that you hate.

  • Richard Korte

    Hey DBB, you want to bring up the subject of welfare. I dont care how racist this will more then likely sound, how do you feel knowing you wont see any form of a pension but Somalian family can bring there 7+ children over to Minnesota and not be registered U.S citisens and receive 2000+ monthly in welfare benefits. Dont take my word for it you can google the monthly benefit amounts for Minnesota MFIP, you will truelly be amazed

    • DBB

      There is a reason we have the largest Somalia population in the country!

  • Carmen

    Good luck finding a job outside of Minnesota. Hint, we have one of the lowest unemployment rates. Only ten states have lower unemployment and I doubt that many people would want to move to Hawaii (very high cost of living), New Hampshire or Vermont. Then there are the Dakotas.

  • Union goon Tom

    Funny we have not heard from Tom Dooher lately.

    • Jake


  • Me

    GOP is nothing but ALEC puppets.

    • we

      HomeAboutInitiativesNewsPublicationsMembersModel LegislationTask ForcesEvents & Meetings
      Our Mission
      Board of Directors
      Private Enterprise Board
      Board of Scholars
      State Chairmen
      Meet our Staff
      Internship Opportunities
      Job Opportunities
      ALEC 101
      Advertising Kit
      Print this Page
      Text-Only Page
      Email this Page

      National Chairman

      Mr. W. Preston Baldwin, Centerpoint360

      First Vice Chairman

      Second Vice Chairman

      Mrs. Sandra Oliver, Bayer Corp.
      Mr. John Del Giorno, GlaxoSmithKline



      Mr. David Powers, Reynolds American
      Ms. Maggie Sans, Wal-Mart Stores

      Chairman Emeritus

      Mr. Jerry Watson

      Private Enterprise Board Members

      Ms. Sano Blocker, Energy Future Holdings
      Mr. Don Bohn, Johnson & Johnson
      Mr. Jeffrey Bond, PhRMA
      Mr. William Carmichael, American Bail Coalition
      Mr. Derek Crawford, Kraft Foods, Inc.
      Mr. Michael Hubert, Pfizer Inc
      Ms. Teresa Jennings, Reed Elsevier, Inc.
      Mr. Kenneth Lane, DIAGEO
      Mr. Bill Leahy, AT&T
      Mr. Kelly Mader, Peabody Energy
      Mr. Richard McArdle, UPS
      Mr. Bernie McKay, Intuit, Inc.
      Mr. Mike Morgan, Koch Companies Public Sector, LLC
      Mr. Gene Rackley, Coca-Cola Refreshments
      Mr. Daniel Smith, Altria Client Services
      Mr. Randy Smith, ExxonMobil Corporation
      Mr. Russell Smoldon, Salt River Project
      Mr. Roland Spies, State Farm Insurance Co.


      PublicationsMembersLoginModel LegislationTask Forces
      Join ALECEvents & MeetingsContact

  • G

    Keep everything shut down and privatize all state jobs. State employees get paid twice what they are worth. You’re ALL living off of Our dime, leaving us only a penny to ourselves. Maybe you can get a job in the private sector holding a traffic sign for $12 an hour instead of the State pair $28 an hour…

    • we

      You are all puppets.

    • KGDD

      State workers do not hold traffic signs, private contractors do and they are paid about $20 per hour. The state workers make sure the contractors do the job according to the law and to the agreed upon contract.

    • Stien

      Great idea G!

      I’m sure State workers won’t mind either, they would simply get paid more to do the same thing! Perect!

  • George Washington

    These state workers should have been speaking up when all the rest of our jobs were being outsourced. They took their boats and went fishing, having long conversation about how wonderful globalization is.

    Suddenly, we’re supposed to get all teary-eyed for them when they had no outrage when our jobs were disappearing, same thing with the teachers. They say “It’s an attack on the middle class”. It’s been an attack on the middle class for a decade, it’s just your turn, that’s why you’re noticing it.

    • Jake

      I agree completely. Amazing how clueless society is nowadays.

      • Darby

        And by your posts, you are the leader of the clueless

  • Me

    For those of you that feel we are overpaid underworked state employees should get off your high horse and come work our jobs, schedules and on our wages before you spout off like you know what you are talking about. YOU HAVE NO CLUE!!!!!

  • Jake

    So why wouldn’t someone without a job want to move to NH, VT, or SD? I have heard for a long time that those states are great places to live. LOW CRIME, reasonable taxes, good schools, interesting topography, places to explore, what’s the problem?

    • KGDD

      You make it sound so great that I wonder why you live in Minnesota yet sing the praises of these states?

      • Jake

        I am seriously considering moving out of Minnesota SOON. Don’t think that I’m NOT. If I do, the ‘state’ will lose. I’m tired of being taken for a FOOL.

        • KGDD

          Not soon enough, 30 years of considering yourself a “fool” is quite a long time

          • Jake

            Well, I always held out that somehow, our state would come to its senses, but I guess that is no longer believable. I also have a lot of family here, but maybe I’ll have to move just a little farther away to try and enjoy some REAL FREEDOM. I’ve seen this state go into steady decline over the last 20 years, and yet, we keep importing all of these east-coasters and every refugee on the planet, and GUESS WHAT, that plan isn’t working very well. So go ahead and turn MN into Michigan’s twin, and see what happens.

            • Recall

              Montana is where I’m headed, I have 20 more years–so have to wait to see the oncoming change ofcourse. There is no reason to live out your retirement here.

        • Stien

          I love it! I’m considering it! Suuuuurrreeeeee you are! And the other guy is going to wait 20 years first! RLMAO! Clowns!

          • Recall

            The other guy is only 39!! I DO plan to move–for certain–it’s what people do -ya know. Go to warmer climates and find tax shelter in FL. They are called “snowbirds” you fool. Drink more coffee before you slam your mundane comments, please.

            • Recall

              @ Whine Stien—No, a statistic is a piece of data that represents a sample—it is a number. See, I aced statistics at the University. That statistic needs to be explained through reason. In this case a hypothesis (an educated guess) would be applied to explain the statistic. I could go on but I think I already lost ya. And read the thread before you spit your nonsense. Did I ever say that all people retire out of state? Forget doing any “research,” it’s lost on your ignoramus kind.

            • Stien

              Awesome! Tell me….how many people move from Minnesota to FLa, AZ, ect once they retire. I have the stats if you’d like to see them. A snowbird is one who WINTERS not lives in another warm weather state. Nice try buddy! I don’t like coffee! I don’t care how old you are… don’t like it like you do, why wait?

              It’ what people do ya’know! LMAO! Actually they don’t! Look it up!
              1. A northerner who moves to a warmer southern state in the winter.
              2. A widespread and variable junco (Junco hyemalis) with gray or brown upper parts and a white belly. Also called northern junco, dark-eyed junco, slate-colored junco. More »

              • Recall

                Hahahaha. I don’t want to spout too many names, it’s not my style. Only when deserved. But I do have some in mind for you. Do a little research—instead of those stats—look at the reality of what the difference is to retire here rather than elsewhere. When you spend your entire life building up a nest egg and put all safety guards in place to protect it, you should, then spend it reasonably and responsibly. MN is NEVER on any list of “Places to Retire”. i promise you that. I can always come back, I own and pay taxes on a lake cabin. So, don’t spend too much time panting on me. I take care of myself–and have a total right to my educated opinion and life choices.

                • Citizen

                  @Recall. George & Barbara Bush listed an apartment in Dallas as their legal home while living in the White House, so they paid NO STATE INCOME tax because Texas doesn’t have one. Nifty little move, eh?

                • Stien

                  Perfect! Pay taxes on your cabin and move. Thank you!

                  Educated opinion? You don’t know stats are formed by doing research. Wow U R Amazing! You are giving your kind ammunition. Clearly the public school system has failed you as well. Most people stay in MN when they retire……simple fact! But nice talking with ya! And good luck trying to move to another state and not pay ANY taxes! Great website out there for you.. To use your words… some research!

                • Recall

                  Oh, and look into residency rules while you’re at it. In the U.S, you are allowed to have a home in one state, and a home in another—allowing you to pick your state of residency–which then becomes the state you pay your taxes. SNOWBIRDS do it all the time.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Thursday Night Football

Listen Live