ST. PAUL (WCCO) — When the last school year started, St. Paul experimented with putting netbooks in the hands of high school students.

It’s a little too early to give the program a grade, but across the country, teens have been using technology as a new way to connect with old subjects.

A federal grant put 50 netbooks in the hands of Cretin-Derham Hall students and gave about 300 more to ninth graders at Harding High School.

“They’re asking me, ‘Have you gotten your netbook?’ I’m like, ‘Yeah I’ve got it.’ They’re like ‘Ah, I wish I would’ve gone to Harding,'” said one student.

It was an experiment that let students use new computer-based learning tools, such as Moodle and Google Docs.

“I really want to teach these kids how to use these tools, because Moodle is being used at colleges and universities across the country. And Google apps is being used by companies and even different cities,” said a teacher.

One of the biggest issues, though, was how the netbooks would hold up, in students’ backpacks when they move to and from class.

“If I’m losing stuff, I’m going to be worried. What are they going to say if I do lose it or break it?” said the student.

And as it turns out, that was a big issue. The Technology Director at Cretin-Derham Hall, Sharon O’Connor, said there was a high rate of damage, even though the netbooks had protective cases.

She blames a design problem with the type of netbook they got, which the manufacturer repaired. O’Conner is still a believer that the type of technology has great potential in schools.

This year, Cretin-Derham Hall will be doing a limited one-on-one trial with iPads with ninth graders to see if that works better.

WCCO-TV tried to find out about Harding’s experience with netbooks, but the PR person with the St. Paul district didn’t return any calls.

Comments (6)
  1. TechRat says:

    iPads.. really? 90% of the workforce is tied to Microsoft’s Office Suite.

    1. M B says:

      …And while the rest of the world was using PCs, the schools all had Apples. How is this different?

  2. pj says:

    Education packaged as entertainment does not work. Reduce costs by going back to teaching basic core skills. Stop wasting tax payer dollars on unnecessary gadgets.

  3. Swamp Rat says:

    What could is technology if the student can’t read, write, or do basic skills work? This technology is waste of taxpayers’ money if used to substitute the basic non-tech skill sets needed to survive in the real world. How can students survive in real world situations if their PDA’s iPads, iPhones, etcetera fail them? That’s why tech gear should be issued in the later grades when students have mastered the basics of the 3-R’s and language skills.

    1. swamp rat says:

      p.s.: pardon the typo–“could” should be “good” in the first sentence.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

More From WCCO | CBS Minnesota

Good Question
Best Of Minnesota

Watch & Listen LIVE