By Bill Hudson

ST. PAUL (WCCO) — The family of a transgender student has settled a human rights lawsuit it served against a St. Paul Charter school.

David and Hannah Edwards enrolled their child at Nova Classical Academy charter school for the 2015-16 school year.

They thought that their 5-year-old boy, who now identifies as a girl, would learn and thrive. But instead, the parents alleged that the school violated their child’s civil rights, by not protecting against gender-based bullying and hostility.

In the early spring of 2016 their story went public, and was discussed openly at school board meetings.

At the time, David Edwards told reporters, “we know from what he has shown us so far that we’re going to need some protections in place in public school.”

Edwards said that the school’s teachers attempted to foster a welcoming and inclusive class environment, but their actions were later blocked by school leadership.

Earlier this summer the school was served with a two-count, civil discrimination lawsuit which demanded policy and training changes.

“They in some ways had no choice,” says attorney, Lisa Stratton.

Stratton is lead counsel for the advocacy group, Gender Justice, which represented the family’s case.

To avoid a costly and protracted court battle, the two sides chose to enter into mediation.

The action proved successful, as an agreement was recently announced that holds the school to transgender policy changes, staff training and gender neutral student uniforms.

“Those things are not small and that kind of awareness creates a welcoming environment and we’re really excited that’s going to be happening at Nova,” Stratton said.

In addition to the policy changes, Nova will pay $120,000 in damages to the Edwards.

Nova Classical Academy attorney, Laura Booth, calls it a fair settlement to all parties involved. She adds that it will make minor revisions and clarifications to the gender inclusion policy that was adopted by Nova in May of 2016.

“It’s best practice for schools to do that training on bullying, on harassment, on the various non-discrimination laws on an annual basis,” Booth added.

The Edwards’ now 7-year-old child withdrew from Nova in 2016 and instead attends a public elementary school.

Attorney Stratton says the lesson in this is for school administrators everywhere to be proactive.

Just a couple of weeks ago, the Minnesota Department of Education released a toolbox of model transgender student policies for schools to consider.

Bill Hudson

Comments (7)
  1. The lawyers and judge should lose their law licenses — Public Schools aren’t allowed to force people to respect liberal religious beliefs.

  2. Susan H says:

    Proud of the Edwards for their support of their child and their advocacy for equality in education and safety of students.

  3. These parents should lose all parental rights to their kid and be placed in custody for child abuse. Liberal Democrat Oregon is doing that right now. Sounds like a good idea for Minnesota.

  4. Lillian Vail says:

    When this first came to the attention of the public about the parents allowing the gender change, I said,”Money will follow.” This was a young child. The adult age is eighteen so why not let the child make the decision at that age.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.