MINNEAPOLIS (WCCO) – Minnesotans are proud of the Bold North, and they’re also proud of their favorite pizza spots – whether it’s Red Savoy’s ‘Sota-style or Punch’s Neapolitan.

But how do Twin Cities pizza shops compare to those on the East Coast?

Providing some context – as well as cause for Midwestern indignation – is Dave Portnoy, the founder of Barstool Sports, who does by-the-slice pizza reviews, among other sports blogger things.

While in town for the Super Bowl, Portnoy – aka Davey Pageviews – tried several Minnesota spots as requested of his audience. All places were critiqued on their cheese slice and off Portnoy’s first bite.

Here’s how they fared:

Black Sheep Coal Fired Pizza (Score: 8.3)


Portnoy actually critiqued Black Sheep’s pizza over the summer, while in town for a Kyle Rudolph charity event. It earned a respectable score of 8.3, with its “cheese drippin’ like a glacier.” No other Minnesota slice earned a higher score. Portnoy really like Black Sheep.

Pizza Lucé (Score: 5:3)


The beloved late-night pizza spot – known for crazy toppings – didn’t do much at all for Portnoy.

“People said Pizza Lucé is good pizza, shame on them,” Portnoy said. “This pizza is like a 5.3. This isn’t good pizza.”

Cossetta (Score: 6.8)


The St. Paul Italian staple fared better than Lucé, but that bite from Black Sheep still looms large.

“It’s a Minnesota mush, bobsled slice,” Portnoy said. “Very cheesy…but Black Sheep puts the beat-down on this.”

Young Joni (Score: 7.6)


Don’t let that “official” score fool you. Portnoy admits that his first bite – the bite of judgement – was taken while the slice from the hip, Northeast Minneapolis pizza joint was still a bit too hot. He suggests, toward the end of his review that his real score for Young Joni was approaching the Black Sheep benchmark.

Football Pizza (Score: 6.8)


For the renamed Crescent Moon Bakery, the response was lukewarm. While Portnoy said the football-shaped pizza was good, it didn’t stop him from smearing it all over his shirt as some sort of joke.

“Football Pizza, it’s actually not a bad description for it,” Portnoy said. “It’s just basic pizza.”


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.