It’s Cheaper To Rent, Right? — Not So Fast

MINNEAPOLIS (WCCO) — Conventional wisdom has always told us it’s cheaper to rent than to buy. But the market just may turn that thought upside down.

The real estate website Trulia tracks rent across the country, and today revealed that in many U.S. cities, renting is no longer the cheaper option.

Joe Grunnet, owner of the Downtown Resource Group in Minneapolis, says in his eyes, buying is becoming the more affordable trend here in the Twin Cities too. His business serves both renters and buyers in the urban condo and loft market, and he sees more of his clients –- an estimated 60 percent — moving into a new phase in this economy. Several years ago, he was leasing more homes.

“It’s a phenomenal time to buy, I always say if you have a solid job and live here 2-3 years you should truly look at buying now,” said Grunnet.

In Minneapolis’ North Loop, Grunnet’s client Glen Dall just may be changing his view.

“My wife and I are entering empty nester stage in life looking to move from suburbs to an urban condo,” he said.

But Dall is currently renting, and worried about rent rising with little apartment vacancy downtown.

“When we run the numbers, I don’t think the advantage is there,” said Dall. “Part of it is psychological. If we will be here for a while, and have our own thing and that sense of ownership.”

The Minneapolis based real estate consulting firm Marquette Advisors tracks the rent prices in the Twin Cities area. In December of 2011, the average rent in the Twin Cities was $927 a month, up nearly 20 dollars from last year at the same time, at $908 a month.

The rental vacancy rate in the Twin Cities during December of 2012 was 2.9 percent, down from 3.9 percent in December of 2011.

To compare to home payments, the Minneapolis Area Association of Realtors says the median home price for March of 2012 is $149,000. Loan officers tell WCCO in a mortgage calculator, the home costing $149,000 would have a mortgage payment could hover near $1,050 a month, with wiggle room for variables like taxes and insurance.

“It’s all timing though,” said Grunnet. “It’s got to make great sense for you as a consumer.”

Mary C. Bujold, President of Maxfield Research, a real estate research and consulting firm in Minneapolis says she wouldn’t be surprised if buying does become the more affordable option. She says her research shows the market is bottoming out in some areas in the country, with the inventory of distressed properties going down, and with historically low interest rates.

Figures from the Minneapolis Area Association of Realtors show pending sales on homes is up roughly 30 percent, compared to this time last year.

The decision is close call for Dall, who says he’ll most likely sign long term over a lease.

“With the market given what it is and interest rates where they are, we will be here for a while, and it might make sense to buy,” said Dall.

  • Fred Hayek

    Read the National Housing Strategy of 1996. Explains origins of housing crisis.

  • djp

    They don’t list all of the money it costs to KEEP a house in shape. With that added on, renting may be the better idea for many people. It is for me!!

  • The other 99%

    There would not be a renting issue if we didn’t give section 8 to everyone and there mommas.

    • Free 99

      And their baby mommas.

  • Who Knew

    “The rental vacancy rate in the Twin Cities during December of 2012 was 2.9 percent, down from 3.9 percent in December of 2011.”

    Wow, I had no idea Lindsey was a fortune teller!

    • Bob

      nice catch, bad reporting, but I guess no one cares anymore

  • dontwory22

    The numbers are all wrong i rent a 3 bed condo i did the math to find a home with all the features i have now would run my 2x as much

  • homeowner

    Real estate swindle is all it is.

  • Pieinsky

    Swindle it is.

  • best printer cartridges

    best printer cartridges

    It’s Cheaper To Rent, Right? – Not So Fast « CBS Minnesota

blog comments powered by Disqus
Thursday Night Football

Listen Live