TALE OF THE TAPE

Tale Of The Tape: Mauer Vs. Love

Joe Mauer and Kevin Love are two of the biggest names currently in Minnesota sports. One’s a Minnesotan born and raised, and the other has helped bring back some relevancy to the Timberwolves.

Mauer is now a multi-million dollar first baseman, but has a bat that only hits singles and is out of the lineup whenever he gets a hangnail. Love gets his statistics on a nightly basis, but isn’t afraid to call out his teammates in the media and hasn’t led his team to the playoffs in six NBA seasons.

Who do you like better in Minnesota, Mauer or Love?

Joe Mauer
Kevin Love
(credit: J. Meric/Getty Images)
(credit: Jordan Johnson/NBAE via Getty Images)
(credit: J. Meric/Getty Images)
(credit: Jordan Johnson/NBAE via Getty Images)
2014 Value
Winner $23 Million
$14.6 Million
Contributions
Winner Mauer has won Gold Gloves, a few batting titles and an MVP award while maintaining one of the most physically demanding positions in sports -- catcher, before a concussion force him to move to first base at the start of the 2014 season.
Love is a scoring and rebounding machine, making his presence known early in his career after one college season at UCLA. He's had a 30-point, 30-rebound game and quickly became the face of the Timberwolves.
Downfalls
Mauer's contract, for one, can be considered a hindrance for the team to get better players in free agency. Fans go nuts on social media when he takes the first strike, and he's still adjusting to life at first base after being behind home plate for so many years. We're also not used to him not performing in clutch situations, and his .267 average this year has the die-hard fans infuriated.
Winner Love is a leader by numbers only. He doesn't play much defense and has yet to lead his team to the playoffs. There was the whole knuckle push-ups debacle, and now he's "vacationing" in his off-time to places that have been known to show interest in his basketball future.
Future
Winner It doesn't appear Mauer is going anywhere. He's married with twin daughters and is under a $184 million contract through 2018 that includes a no-trade clause that he would have to waive to go elsewhere. He's the face of the Twins, but is it on him to carry the team to the playoffs and beyond and do Minnesotans want him to stay?
Love has one year left on his current contract and signs indicate he has no intention of staying in Minnesota. If he chooses to become a free agent, the Timberwolves are likely to trade him and get some value for him before he can walk. But does the organization have the guts to get rid of its biggest asset?

The Winner Is

(credit: J. Meric/Getty Images)
Winner Joe Mauer
3 out of 4

Joe Mauer is the overall winner because he's "one of us," being from St. Paul, and Minnesota sports fans are obsessed with this concept. He's also as even-keeled as it gets when it comes to baseball, which for fans can be as maddening as it is refreshing. All can be forgiven if Mauer can help get the Twins to a World Series, or at least make some sort of playoff run.

MORE TALES OF THE TAPE

  1. (credit: CBS) (credit: CBS)
    Better Acquisition: Kevin Garnett Or Torii Hunter?

    These two moves are the most recent in a series of moves where Minnesota sports teams are bringing back fan favorites who left after starting their careers here. So it begs the question, who’s the better acquisition, Garnett for the Timberwolves or Hunter for the Twins?

  2. (credit: Andy Lyons/Getty Images) (credit: Alex Goodlett/Getty Images)
    Can The Gophers Still Make The NCAA Tournament?

    After losing at Indiana Sunday night, the Gophers are 16-10 overall and 5-8 in Big Ten play with five games remaining. Do they still have a chance to make the Big Dance? Here’s why they will and why they won’t.

  3. Members of the New England Patriots celebrate with the Vince Lombardi Trophy after defeating the Seattle Seahawks 28-24 in Super Bowl XLIX. Recording artist Katy Perry performs onstage during the Pepsi Super Bowl XLIX Halftime Show.
    Was Super Bowl XLIX Or Katy Perry’s Halftime Show More Exciting?

    I don’t usually watch Super Bowl halftime shows. But when I do, it has Katy Perry. How did her performance measure up to the game?

See All Tales of the Tape
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 4,393 other followers